...If you guys are in for some LOLs, check out the reviews for sugar free gummi bears on Amazon. They aren't vegan, but the reviews tell hilarious tales of the woes sugar free candy can bring! It's trolling at it's best!
http://www.amazon.com/Haribo-Gummi-...ywords=sugar+free+gummy+bears#customerReviews
Best laugh in a long time, some of those making my jaw ache

Thanks for sharing those humorous reviews.
I'm not fully vegan, but I'm vegetarian... would just do toys, too, if I were you.
Same here. I agree with a non-food alternative likely being the best possible way to go. In addition to a sticker and small toy (spider ring or rubber bat, perhaps?), you could also opt to throw in a pencil (kids practically eat those, some
literally) and temporary tattoo.