What about a gc to a coffee shop and a basket of baked goodies?
Most of our prizes this year were along those lines. A package of Chinese finger traps, a little "gone fishin" game, themed mugs and tumblers, etc. Some of our most popular prizes have been Halloween-themed photo frames, a Frankenstein punching pen (I think we got it at Party City), a hot sauce in a skull-shaped bottle, some themed costume jewelry, and a Chicken-n-Egg stress ball (this thing was hilarious and gross).Yep, I agree! My prize winners will be getting cheap, tacky dollar store prizes and candy!