I'm having the same trouble James. I wanted 2 "minute to win it" style games for ease and quickness as my crowd has struggled in the past...
Here's a couple I thought of
•Walk the plank...have them carry something from one end of the plank to the other-maybe tea and fill up a tankard (this could b done in teams). This will prove tricky for those who have had a bit to drink...
View attachment 221057
•Oreo game...this is a minute to win it game where guests put an oreo on their forehead and have to work it all the way down their face to their mouth. It's not very piratey aside from it looks like an eye patch as it makes its way over the eye. Still it is fast, hilarious and makes for great pics.
View attachment 221058
There's also several ring toss games (captain hook board and one looks like a box with a sword in it) though they're intended for kiddos I think they might fit the bill for our crowd
View attachment 221059
View attachment 221060