Arlita, I just remembered that I bought a reindeer motor from ebay a couple of years ago. It does not have the plastic case but forum members have said this is the same motor that is in the reindeer replacement motors from Kindy's. This might be an option for you. The one I bought worked very well and reverses just like the ones I have purchased from Kindy's. This is the one I bought. It is $3.60 plus $2.99 shipping. I think this is the same motor Mad Max uses. If Mad Max still has any he puts them in a plastic case and puts the electric plug on them. On this one you will have to put a plug on the end of the wires. Hope this helps you out.