I found some jars in the Sale section of Lakeside.com that would fit in with Halloween decor. Some of the reviews mention the lids not fitting correctly.
https://www.lakeside.com/Home-Decor/Decorative-Accents/Decorative-Accents/Elegant-Glass-Jars//prod1120092.jmp?categoryId=
https://www.lakeside.com/Home-Decor/Decorative-Accents/Decorative-Accents/Elegant-Glass-Jars//prod1120092.jmp?categoryId=