Nice bottle and label - I love Michaels!
Karo syrup (or pancake syrup) with a little bit of red food coloring. It will look thicker than water and give you more of a blood effect. Mix the food coloring into it before you put it in the bottle (might have to thin it out a tiny bit with a tea spoon of water). And don't forget to empty it out of the bottle for storage (that could get gross if you store it with the syrup in there!)
I personally would save it to use on pancakes after Halloween as long as the bottle was washed prior to putting the syrup in there - bloody pancakes!
There are all sorts of potion/apothecary bottle threads on the forum with lots of ideas for stuff you can put into bottles to match their labels... definitely do some searching around these parts.
Karo syrup (or pancake syrup) with a little bit of red food coloring. It will look thicker than water and give you more of a blood effect. Mix the food coloring into it before you put it in the bottle (might have to thin it out a tiny bit with a tea spoon of water). And don't forget to empty it out of the bottle for storage (that could get gross if you store it with the syrup in there!)
I personally would save it to use on pancakes after Halloween as long as the bottle was washed prior to putting the syrup in there - bloody pancakes!
There are all sorts of potion/apothecary bottle threads on the forum with lots of ideas for stuff you can put into bottles to match their labels... definitely do some searching around these parts.