Here's my list. I am perfectly ok with thrifted or 2nd hand items!
I am calling my theme "the Creepy Crafter"
Spell book pages, can just be free printed pages, wiccan, dark and creepy. Would love the McBeth witches poem!
Potion labels, small to medium sized. Again can be free printed ( I don't have a printer) can be dark or fun, or both!
Small bells, vintage looking, either antique style jingle bells, or Asian or cow bell style,
Charms, wiccan, witch or Halloween type, silver or gold.
Emphemera, (sp?), images, tags, inks, paper doilies for junk journals( witchy-dark- gothic- vintage- shabby chic style).
Beads of all types- fancy trims for fabric, golds and silver filigree type.
Natural/nature items. Crystals, gems, pretty stones.
Celestial symbols,(the sun, moon, stars) in any type ( charms, jewelry, wood, etc)
Crocheted or tatted vintage ( or vintage style) doily or lace. Creams, whites, colors, all work!
Small wooden shapes and boxes.
Items to make steam punk crafts.
I am putting together a board to give ideas on Pinterest!
I might add to this if I think of something else