I think it is fine! It is all in how you incorporate him into the overall scene. We have a huge headless horseman that the in laws gave hubs one year for his bday. It has never fit with our overall themes over the years...but we still put him out. And you know what? He is always well received and we get comments about him every year. I find we are often way more critical of our set ups than the general public. I say go for it!