Went to Five Below today and they have some props - not a huge selection, but I was happy with what they had. Tombstones for $3, fairly large skulls with lights in them for $5, a 3-D reaper looking through a stone window (good for a dungeon scene) and my favorite, a metal cage (ornate) with a woman's head hanging inside for $5!!!!
They also have a couple of horror movie DVDs on sale for $5, stone looking signs for $1! and some funny t-shirts that look like costumes in themselves (e.g. doctor's outfit).
Here's the ad - hurry, sale is currently on.
Five Below > About Us > Ads