Thanks Mr. Chicken and Halloweiner!
Halloweiner, Can you send it to my email? I'll pm you.
Dino, I have a bad copy of the Kay Starr version so I'll take anything over the version I have! I'll pm you!
Supposedly some artist named Kat or Kay Kyser recorded on too! and that's the one that turns up little info on google!
I can't find it anywhere!
UPDATE* According to many google pages there's a version of the Headless Horseman by Kay Kyser (vocal by Freddie Froghammer)
I can't find an album, cassette, mp3 or anything. Weird.