Um, I like detail so this list might be kind of long, but I promise I'll be happy with anything Reaper!

For the first time, we’re skipping our big outdoor party, so this list will be more personal wants and likes than I’ve had in the past.
Likes:
General Halloween: Can always use lights, creepy cloth, cheesecloth, creepy critters, skeletons, bones, and pumpkins.
Victorian things: I like decorations, costuming, jewelry, and anything steampunky. I love colored glass and long pendant-style necklaces.
Day of the Dead: Sugar skulls, skeleton figures, etc.
Literature: Edgar Allan Poe, Sleepy Hallow, etc. I like ghost stories and books on weird local legends and oddities. Since I live here, I already have a lot about California, but I’d love to learn about other places.
Apothecary: I have a few very nice potion bottles (thanks former reapers!), but I love other types of curiosities. I will, of course, always take more awesome bottles.
Miniatures: I’d love one of those tin box (Altoids) miniature scenes. Or the mini terrariums. Actually, I just like miniature stuff in general. If that’s your thing Reaper, go crazy.
Halloween Village: Love, love, love anything for my Halloween Village. I’ve been collecting and repainting Dollar Store pieces for a while now, so I’m not looking for anything expensive. Something cheap or second hand that I can repaint is great. Bits and pieces such as trees, shrubs, moss, fences, etc. are greatly needed too since I really want to build up the "grounds" this year.
Spiders: My favorite Halloween motif. I love ‘em all. Realistic, fuzzy, big, small…
Music: Finding new (to me) Halloween music makes me happy.
Disney: I’m a huge, huge Disney and Disneyland fan! Anything from the Haunted Mansion is great. Love the wallpaper print and all of the characters. Love Nightmare Before Christmas. And I love all things Disney Villains!
If you can sew, I would be super happy with anything you make. Sewing is like watching magic for me. I know there's a trick, but I've yet to figure it out.
I also always appreciate bits and pieces I can work/craft with--ribbon, tape, glue, styrofoam, wood, broken or imperfect jewerlry bits, even glitter.
Make, buy, recycle, upcycle, or re-gift it, whatever works for you Reaper. I’ll be a happy victim!
Dislikes: Blood, gore, zombies
I have a Secret Reaper Pinterest board. It has both things that I like and things that I want to work on for victims on it. Feel free to snoop through the other boards as well. We all do it.
Pinterest
Small addition: Reaper, you might want to avoid real candles or items that can melt easily. I live in the desert and sometimes things like that don't survive to the doorstep.