What about doing tempt your fate but make big voodoo doll(s) (made with a loose weave burlap) and pins, have fates written on the pins (wooden dowel or even a pencil and styrofoam ball) and have the pins inserted into the dolls. When they pull a pin they find out their fate. A good fate could be a shot of alcohol (I put mine in jello cups with lids in a big bin) and bad fates are shots of pickle juice, tuna juice, vinegar, hot sauce, etc. (Remember to have one bin for good and one for bad)
*instead of writing on the pin u could just dip the pointed end in paint...pick 2 colored bins for your drinks and the pins will match.
As the party continues u can reinsert the pins so the game continues