Thanks for your response! I finally figured it out. I took apart the little black rectangular box that the Try Me button plugs into. I thought it was the actual sensor, but turns out it's just a headphone jack, but a little larger. Inside there were a couple of wires and one of them had come loose! My husband soldered it back on and Pumpkin Nester is working again!
Here's a couple of photos incase anyone else experiences the same problem:
This is the jack where the button plugs in:
View attachment 229913
Here are the 4 screws on the box that I had to remove to open it up
View attachment 229914
Here is the plug jack and you can see the white wire has come off
View attachment 229915