I'm in

We had a great year for both pumpkins and gourds last year, although mine were ready several weeks after most others on here. I plan to try some big pumpkins, but in my climate, I don't think I'd do well in a competition! I want to try Prizewinner. They're smaller than Atlantic Giants, but can still get over 100 lbs, plus I like the shape and color-- deeper orange and less prone to ooze and flatten. No disrespect to Atlantic Giants-- I absolutely love the way they can be carved! Pretty amazing!
LadyMage-- it's hard to know what to do, isn't it? It will be a temptation to plant early, but a sudden switch to more typical weather can really make a mess of things!
I agree wholeheartedly with Col. Fryght about buying good seeds. Re-using gathered seed is a gamble, and a pack of seeds costs only about as much as a single pumpkin costs many places. It can be fun to try a few of your own plants' seeds if you have plenty of space, but I wouldn't put all my proverbial eggs in that basket. If you have species plants (that had closed pollination) it's fine, but with hybrids, there's no telling what you'll get. It might be great, or might not. There's even a chance of producing sterile plants that will grow beautifully, but not produce any pumpkins. Nothing wrong with giving gathered seeds a try-- just be aware, as I said, it's a gamble.
Did you grow batwings last year, Brian? If so, how did they do for you? They didn't do as well for me as other varieties. Mine were virally blighted-- lumpy & with mosaic patterns in the leaves. It didn't show up until mid season, but it showed up
only in that variety-- several plants, with other varieties planted in between. Either it was a much more vulnerable variety, or I bought infected seeds. (I got a few decent pumpkins from them-- those that set early. I picked them fairly early, then dug and burned the vines.)
I never plant an entire packet, but I'll use left-overs for 2-3 years. They retain viability well. After I get plants started, I'll try to remember to list what I have plenty of, and offer to share a couple each of varieties where I have plenty-- for people who'd like to try one hill but don't want to buy an entire packet. (I won't offer any of the old Batwing seed; I tossed those, just in case.)