birthday party

What would be the better gift between these two for my niece on her birthday who will turn 4 by Nov 15? Girl's Beach Kit or Panda Pillow Other ideas are also welcome but keep in mind that I am already giving her Halloween gift so I am a little bit out of the budget for an expensive gift :(...

Black rose circus sweet 16 (Dark Circus party 2014) Next year it's my sweet 16 and for awhile I've been wanting to do a gothic/twisted circus theme but so far I have not came up with any good ideas so I was wondering if anyone had any good ideas. There will be about 10 girls around 15/16...