There has to be something in between cutesy/traditional decor and bloody/rotting decor. I do a bloodless haunt but want it to be scary, not cute. That's why I wind up making everything myself. I can pick up some creepy animals - rats, vultures, crows, snakes, scorpions, etc. - but if I want a premade moving prop, forget it. I wind up having to strip it apart and rebuild it to not be super cute or super gory. I'm dreading the redo of the Michaels trick-or-treat witch prop this year: mine has the hands installed backwards and the bag installed inside out
I can't be the only bloodless haunt on the block, so to speak. Bloody isn't the same as scary.
I like strange. Nightmarish, if you will. The themes I've done thus far: abandoned fairgrounds (the most traditional, but still a bit off: bright purple, orange, and green paint on booths, flyers, signs, and zomie attendants), living garden (pumpkin snakes, giant maneating plants, assorted animalistic plants), deep green sea (undersea haunt: giant squid, electric eel, threatening fish, and if they didn't collapse under a failed giant whale: mermaids, sharks, and fighting sailors), and Jabberwocky (based on the Lewis Carroll poem: various creatures of all different sizes, plants, and a gigantic jabberwocky). So I guess I'm suggesting different monsters not covered in blood. Things that make a ToTer and their family stop, stare, and ask "what's that?" Tradition has it's place, but that's rarely the case in my vision. Sure, I enjoy making my own props, but when I have massive failures the week of Halloween, I'm screwed. It'd be nice to supplement my own output with quality props not covered in blood.