I'm making a couple columns that'll have masks atached to them and painted to look like stone. I was thinking along the line of fiberglass, the kind from Wal-Mart. Just carefully lining the inside of the mask to make it hold it's shape. I tried an experimental patch of mask and it worked. I was going to try Great Stuff but I didn't want the distarted face like you mentioned.
__________________
^v^ ^v^ ^v^
^v^ ^v^ ^v^
|