Well here in the UK our candy is quite different, and I sadly never went TOTing growing up, but last year I did have the absolute pleasure of being sent a parcel of Halloween candy by Cadaverino, and got the chance to sample some of the things you guys and gals have mentioned. (Also got some from a couple of other transatlantic friends over the years so have sampled quite a bit now lol!)
Loved: Nerds and Pixi Stix!!! (Ok, not strictly Halloween candy but goodness me anything that sour can't be a bad thing lol) oh and of course Reese's Peanut Butter Cups (I have a slight addiction), Sour Skittles, Sugar Babies and Halloween M&Ms
Liked: Candy Corn/Autumn Mix (although not as much as my OH did - he nearly ate the whole bag haha!), Tootsie Rolls
Didn't like: Hershey's Kisses (too sugary & powdery), Popcorn balls - I prefer my popcorn hot and buttery hehe ^_^;
My favourite Halloween candies that we get in the UK are the Halloween chocolate range they do at Thornton's Chocolatiers and the Haribo Spooky Mix