Last year was my first year giving out gift bags. I used brown paper lunch bags and glued hand made brooms to them. I just went outside and collected a bunch of branches , tied them together with wire and voila!
Inside i put the little water bottles with some advil packets (the sinlge packets) hot glued to the neck of the bottle. I figured some people would wake up with headaches

. Of course there was chocolate, and some printed "fortunes" inside. I know there was something else...but i cant remember.
Everyone seemed to like them. ANd i t was fairly inexpensive.