How about The Blue Oyster Cult classic "Dont Fear the Reaper"? However, I would suggest using one of the many covers for the teen audience, might i sugget the cover of Dont fear the Reaper by H.I.M. (His Infernal Majesty, if anyone here isnt familiar with the artist)? This cover has a really eerie sound to it, so it just might work.

<center></center>